Sitely and Google Sitemap - ZERO hits not recognized by Google

Had a URL, host with SSL GoDaddy for years, and just updated my Sitley site (from the Old Sparkle).

Novice. More of a hobbyist. But you know…

Anyway, went into Google Analytics about 2 months ago - have tried multiple time to submit my Sitely designed site - keeps getting rejected. You literally can’t find my site via a Google Search. Blogs, and random sites come up, and mine just doesn’t.

My site is: www.blackhawkwar.com

About to move off GoDaddy and just go with Wordpress. I enjoy Sitely but just doesn’t seem to be a good option for monthly/random website amateurs.

I don’t think the platform or development environment would be a reason for Google to reject your website for indexing. So, moving your site to a Wordpress environment is unlikely to improve the situation.

Google can reject or delay a website’s indexing for several reasons. Most are technical or quality-related rather than punitive. Here are the main causes, explained plainly.

The most common reason is that Google cannot access the site properly. If your pages return errors such as 404 (not found), 403 (forbidden), or 5xx server errors, Googlebot may give up. This also happens if your server is slow, times out, or blocks Google’s IP addresses.

Another frequent cause is that indexing has been explicitly blocked. A robots.txt file may be disallowing Googlebot, or your pages may contain a noindex meta tag or HTTP header. This is surprisingly easy to overlook, especially on sites that were recently in development or staging.

Thin or low-quality content is a major factor. If a site has very little original text, heavily duplicated content, auto-generated pages, or pages that exist mainly to redirect users elsewhere, Google may crawl it but choose not to index it. This often shows up in Search Console as “Crawled – currently not indexed”.

New or low-authority sites can also be ignored temporarily. If a site has no inbound links, minimal content, or no clear topical focus, Google may deprioritise it until it sees signals that the site is legitimate and useful.

Policy or guideline violations can trigger rejection. This includes spammy practices such as keyword stuffing, cloaking, doorway pages, scraped content, or misleading behaviour. In more serious cases, a manual action may be applied, which will be visible in Google Search Console.

Poor site structure can be an issue. If internal links are broken, pages are orphaned, or navigation relies heavily on JavaScript that Google struggles to render, Google may not discover or understand your content well enough to index it.

Duplicate or canonical issues are another common cause. If Google believes another URL is the “main” version of your page, it may choose that one instead and exclude the version you submitted. This often happens with HTTP vs HTTPS, www vs non-www, or parameterised URLs.

Finally, security or trust problems can stop indexing. Sites that are hacked, infected with malware, or lack basic HTTPS security may be excluded to protect users.

If you want to diagnose a specific rejection, Google Search Console is essential. The “Pages” (Indexing) report will usually tell you whether the page is blocked, crawled but not indexed, duplicated, or affected by a policy issue.

3 Likes

Mmmm… A strange one!
For me all the Sitely websites I have created out in the wild rank very high on the likes of Google, Bing, etc…

I have had a quick look at your site and two big ones stand out…

  • You do not have a mobile version? Google (and most of the other search engine) nowadays prioritise “mobile first”, so if you don’t have a mobile version of your website then the search engines do penalise you.
  • You are inconsistent with your “alt” tags regarding your images. These are a goldmine as you can really improve your on page SEO by making sure all your images are alt-tagged.

The other thing is have you followed the instructions to connect your Sitely site to Google Analytics? You connect your Sitely site to your already signed up for Google Analytics via the Settings / Verification. You can find out more here - Site Settings | Sitely Documentation

ADDITIONAL: Also it is always a good idea to use Sitely’s Website Assistant where it makes suggestions (after assessing your site) to improve your on page SEO.

3 Likes

When I use the Website Assistant I get warnings that aren’t relevant. Link URL not valid warning when there is no link on that element (button), Linked page does not exist, where On Click is Next Page. I use a lot of copy and paste elements and change or remove links often. Perhaps things get jumbled over time. Have you seen this issue at all?

1 Like

I think the word “assistant” tells me it is just a guide, but it would be great if it was much more than that! Like when it alerts me to the meta description saying it should be a certain number but then doesn’t tell me if I have gone over that number. :slight_smile:

I have also noticed what you have mentioned here @gsstamas, but I think it would be best to screenshot what Website Assistant does and let Duncan know how it doesn’t make sense in what it is doing. That reminds me, I’d best send my project because Website Assistant is telling me a white on black is not enough contrast! :frowning:

3 Likes

Hi Everyone - thanks for the great advice! This has been supremely frustrating - It ended up being a GoDaddy SSL Issue - NOT SITELY.

Here is the short story - I had about 20 domains with GoDaddy for years, and just a few I had created basic Sitely websites. In July 2025, I purchased 5 SSL certificates, which GoDaddy somehow sells as a package and I guess stacks into one Certificate. The upshot is that for about 8 months this was done incorrectly on GoDaddy’s side - so while if you had the actual URL typed into the search engine you could land on the page, it wasn’t discoverable via search engines.

It took me literally, monthly calls to GoDaddy to eventually figure this out. I’m going to start moving all my sites and domains off GoDaddy. Their techs were just terrible, and would never believe what I was experiencing.

Greatly appreciate everyone’s feedback on this site - I hope this may help others. Basically, be wary of GoDaddy SSL service.

2 Likes